CA (Chartered Accountant) vs CS (Company Secretary) | A Brief Comparison

CA vs CS: Everyone wishes to have the best career which has great career opportunities, a good salary, and a good job profile as well. If you are on your way to choose the best career in the commerce stream then here you go. There are a lot of career opportunities for commerce stream students. If you also think CA vs CS which is better, then go through the blog to know the brief comparison. We have listed out differences between the two i.e., Chartered Accountant orCompany Secretary to make your decision easier.

What is CA (Chartered Accountant)?

You might be knowing that CA is the most reputed course in the commerce stream. The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI), which is the second largest accounting body throughout the world, is the only authority to give the CA degree and conduct the exam.

Chartered Accountant (CA) is well known for earning high incentives in the corporate world and also held responsible for handling the financial and legal matters of the company. The profession is challenging because a CA is always required to update himself with the amended laws and case studies. A person who is an expert in CA is aware of various domains such as accounting, auditing, taxation, finance, corporate laws. He/she is eligible to get appointed on various job profiles such as Internal Auditor, Portfolio Management, Finance Advisor, etc.

What is CS (Company Secretary)?

Company Secretary is another reputed course in the commerce stream. It is comparatively a less tougher examination as compared to CA. The CS course is conducted by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India (ICSI) and offers a CS degree.

The Company Secretary (CS) is also an equally good professional option for commerce and other graduates alike. There are immense opportunities and scope for CS professionals in the field of the private sector, public sector, banks, stock exchange, law firms, and other financial institutions.

A Brief Comparison between CA vs CS

cs-vs-ca

Below is the table consisting of a detailed comparison between CA vs CS. Go through the table to know in detail.

Parameter CA CS
Course Structure CA course is divided into three levels

  • CA Foundation
  • CA Intermediate
  • CA Final

along with three years of practical training. One can enroll for the entrance examination of the CA Foundation after qualifying 12th standard.

CS is also divided into three levels

  • CS Foundation,
  • CS Executive
  • CS Professional

One can take up the CS Foundation programme after completion of 10+2 or equivalent.

Duration The total duration of the CA Course is a minimum of 4.5 years including 3 years of articleship training. The total duration of the CS course is a minimum of 2.5 years.
Job Profile A CA can work on multiple Job Profiles such as –

  1. Statutory Audit.
  2. Internal Audit
  3. Advisor in Direct or Indirect Taxation
  4. Handling Transfer Pricing
  5. Financial and Accounting Management
  6. Investment Decisions
  7. System Audit (after clearing DISA/CISA)
  8. Handling the company’s Legal Matters etc.
A CS can be appointed in the following job profiles

  1. Legal Experts
  2. Corporate Planner
  3. Strategic Manager
  4. Chief Advisor
  5. Executive Secretary
  6. Capital Market and Investor Relations
Average Salary A fresher Chartered Accountant can be offered an average salary of 6-7 lakhs which increases with experience and ability. However, the candidates who passed out in the first attempt are usually offered 10-12 lakhs and Rank Holders gets to offer up to 25 lakhs. A fresher Company Secretary can earn up to 3-5 lakhs per annum. Based on the rank and marks, the salary might increase.
Expertise A CA needs to have a lot of Quantitative ability. A CA must be accurate in numbers. A CS needs to have a Qualitative approach to his/her career. CS should be good in law and management.
Authority A CA can be a lawyer in favor of the client. But, a CA doesn’t have the authority to defend his client or represent him in any case.
Hiring Priority CA’s are mainly hired by audit and consulting firms and firms with global repute. CS’s are being hired by public enterprises and government organizations.
Pass Percentage
  • CA Foundation pass percentage: 30 – 40%
  • CA Intermediate pass percentage: 15% – 25%
  • CA Final pass percentage: 10 – 15%
  • CS Foundation pass percentage: 40 – 60%
  • CA Executive pass percentage: 10% – 15%
  • CA Professional pass percentage: 15 – 20%

Major Differences Between CA and CS

There are Some major Difference Between CA and CS

Expertise

  • Chartered Accountant needs more Quantitative Ability than Qualitative Ability whereas Company Secretary need more Qualitative Ability
  • CA Should be Good at Analytical Skills and Numbers
  • CA needs more Accuracy with Numbers and there is shouldn’t be a Place for Errors and Also be able to handle Pressure
  • CS should have Very Excellent Communication and Knowledge of Law and Management is a must.

Authority

CA can Defend His/her Client and Act as a lawyer when Necessary, but CS Doesn’t have such Authority.

Focus

  • The main focus for CA Course is Quantitative Aptitude, Accounting, where as CS Course focus will be on Qualitative ability, Corporate Law, and Communication
  • CA Comprises of Various Subjects of Accounting whereas CS is more of Soft Skills and Technical Skills

Hiring Priority

  • CA’s are hired by Audit and Consulting firms, whereas Public Organizations and Government bodies will Hire Company Secretary
  • CA and CS will be hired by other Industries as Well

CA vs CS Salary in India

  • CA Gets more Salary than CS, most of Companies Prefer CA’s and It has more Career Opportunities
  • CA Freshers will get a salary of 6-7 LPA but CS Freshers will get 3-5 LPA
  • Salary Percentage of Both CS and CA Increases as with Experience, talent, and Work

Thus, it depends upon the interest of the candidate. You can opt for any one of the both between CA vs CS. Remember to choose the best career out of both based on your interests. You can excel in CS Exams with a wide range of CS Preparation Books available for all three levels. Choose the best career among CA vs CS.

Leave a Comment